الأثر المؤجل للأحكام الصادرة بعدم الدستورية "دراسة تحليلية مقارنة في ضوء قضاء المجلس الدستوري الفرنسي والمحكمة الدستورية العليا المصرية"

Faculty Law Year: 2024
Type of Publication: ZU Hosted Pages:
Authors:
Journal: المجلة القانونية كلية الحقوق-جامعة القاهرة-فرع الخرطوم Volume:
Keywords : الأثر المؤجل للأحكام الصادرة بعدم الدستورية "دراسة    
Abstract:
The validity of rulings issued as unconstitutional has a time range, which is to determine the date to which the effects of the ruling extend. This range includes three possibilities, the first of which is the retroactive effect of the ruling of unconstitutionality, the second of which is the immediate and direct effect of the ruling of unconstitutionality, and finally, which is a relatively recent matter in some countries, which is Deciding to postpone the implementation of the ruling issued as unconstitutional for a specific period to avoid the constitutional defect caused by the legislator. What is meant by the deferred effect of the ruling of unconstitutionality is that the constitutional judge may set a deadline within which the effect of the ruling of unconstitutionality will be relaxed, as the constitutional judge shall judge the unconstitutionality of a text in a law or regulation, while postponing and postponing the effectiveness of the effects of that ruling for a specific period on a date subsequent to the date of publication of the ruling of unconstitutionality. This is if the immediate or retroactive enforcement of the effects of that ruling will result in serious consequences, will not put an end to the existing defect of unconstitutionality, or will result in the creation of a new unconstitutional situation. After postponing the effects of the unconstitutional ruling, the constitutional judge adopted several solutions regarding determining the consequences that the implementation bodies will have to extract during the temporary period that extends from the date of publishing their decision until the time of intervention by the legislator, or at the latest until the specified date of cancellation, and these solutions are represented by acknowledging retroactivity. Procedural, while the second solution is based on acknowledging the validity of the disputes, as the Council decides that the measures taken pursuant to the ruling that was declared unconstitutional cannot be appealed on the basis of this unconstitutionality, while the final solution is embodied in resorting to transitional interpretation reservations, as they are a special type of interpretation reservations. It is necessarily of a temporary nature, because it only covers the period from the decision of the Constitutional Council until the repeal of the legislative text declaring it unconstitutional.
   
     
 
       

Author Related Publications

  • Mohamed Mesbah Mohamed Elnagy, "الضمانات الدستورية لحماية الخصوصية الجينية-دراسة تحليلية مقارنة"", كلية الحقوق-جامعة السادات, 2022 More
  • Mohamed Mesbah Mohamed Elnagy, "قرينة السببية في مجال المسئولية الإدارية "دراسة تحليلية مقارنة"", كلية الحقوق-جامعة المنصورة, 2024 More
  • Mohamed Mesbah Mohamed Elnagy, "الرقابة القضائية على التزام السلطات العامة بتطبيق مبدأ الحيطة لمواجهة المخاطر المحتملة (دراسة مقارنة)", كلية الحقوق-جامعة القاهرة-فرع الخرطوم, 2024 More
  • Mohamed Mesbah Mohamed Elnagy, "دور القضاء الإداري المستعجل الموضوعي في حماية مبادئ العقود الإدارية "دراسة تحليلية مقارنة"", كلية الحقوق-جامعة السادات, 2025 More

Department Related Publications

  • Medhat Ahmed Mohamed Yusif, "ضمانات حقوق ذوي الإعاقة في مصر بين الواقع والمأمول "دراسة مقارنة", مجلة القاهرة ـــ فرع الخرطوم, 2021 More
  • Medhat Ahmed Mohamed Yusif, "المركز القانوني للمتعاقد من الباطن الخفي في العقـــــــــود الإداريــــــــة " دراســــــة مقارنــــــــة"", مجلة جامعة القاهرة ـــ فرع الخرطوم, 2020 More
  • Medhat Ahmed Mohamed Yusif, "الحماية الدستورية لحق الإنسان في الصحة في ظل النظام العام "دراسة مقارنة"", مجلة جامعة القاهرة ـــ فرع الخرطوم, 2019 More
  • Medhat Ahmed Mohamed Yusif, "مدى ذاتية التحكيم في عقود المشاركة بين القطاعين الحكومي والخاص - دراسة مقارنة -", مجلة جامعة المنوفية, 2020 More
  • Medhat Ahmed Mohamed Yusif, "حدود السلطة الرئاسية في انعقاد المسئولية المدنية وثورة الخامس والعشرين من يناير (2011)", مجلة جامعة المنوفية, 2020 More
Tweet