Transobturator hybrid tape versus synthetic tape in treatment of female stress urinary incontinence: A prospective randomized clinical study الشريط الهجين عبر العضلة العاصرة مقابل الشريط الصناعي في علاج سلس البول الإجهادي عند النساء: دراسة سريرية عشوائية مستقبلية

Faculty Medicine Year: 2025
Type of Publication: ZU Hosted Pages:
Authors:
Journal: Urologia Journal Urologia Journal Volume:
Keywords : Transobturator hybrid tape versus synthetic tape    
Abstract:
objective: To compare the clinical and operative outcomes of transobturator hybrid tape versus synthetic tapes during mid-urethral sling in treating female stress urinary incontinence (SUI). Patients and methods: This prospective randomized study included 63 women with SUI. Patients were categorized into two groups: Group I included 32 patients who underwent midurethral sling procedure using hybrid tape; and Group II included 31 patients that had synthetic sling, using transobturator tape approach (TOT) in both groups. Two patients in group I lost to follow up and one patient in group II lost to follow up. The primary endpoint was the safety of sling erosion and major complications. The 2ry endpoint was the efficacy that was assessed objectively by the Cough stress test and subjectively by International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire-Urinary Incontinence Short Form (ICIQ-UI-SF) and this was assessed at 1, 6, and 12 months. The following variables were compared: operative time, post-operative pain scores, duration of indwelling urethral catheter, hospital stay, and quality of life (QoL) assessment (International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire-Urinary Incontinence Short Form [ICIQ-UI-SF]) assessing the continence status before and after discharge from hospital. Results: Patients among the two groups were normally distributed with no statistical significant difference in patient's demographic data and comorbidities. The hybrid tape procedure had a longer mean (SD) operative time of 45.3 ± 3.6 min, which was longer than that of synthetic tape procedure, at a mean (SD) of 29.5 ± (3.5) min. This increase was statistically significant (p < 0.001). The mean time to return to normal activity was significantly shorter in Group II patients compared to those in Group I. Overall cure rate (defined as no more episodes of SUI or pad use) was statistically insignificant in both groups being 86.7% and 83.3% respectively. No bladder, vascular, nervous or intestinal injuries were encountered in either group. Pain was significantly higher in hybrid tape (Group I). Post operative urgency, and urge incontinence rates were not significantly different between in both groups. Two cases in group 1 and one case in the other group, and these cases were managed by medical treatment. Vaginal sling erosion was encountered in one case in group II which was managed by sling removal. Conclusion: Hybrid tape may be considered as a treatment option during TOT for female SUI with comparable efficacy and safety to synthetic tape. Long term follow up should be considered.
   
     
 
       

Author Related Publications

  • Karim Mahmoud Taha Setta, "Role of shear wave elastography (SWE) in erectile dysfunction patients for evaluation of daily tadalafil treatment outcome دور التصوير الإلستوجرافي لموجة القص (SWE) في مرضى ضعف الانتصاب لتقييم نتائج عـلاج تادالافيل اليومية", World Journal of Urology, 2022 More
  • Karim Mahmoud Taha Setta, "Urodynamic Findings in Children with Refractory Nocturnal Enuresis النتائج الديناميكية البولية لدى الأطفال المصابين بسلس البول الليلي المقاوم للعلاج", Zagazig University Medical Journal, 2023 More
  • Karim Mahmoud Taha Setta, "Novel Autologous Coated midurethral sling versus synthetic sling in treatment of Female Stress urinary incontinence;Prospective Randomized Controlled Trial الشريط المهبلي الفريد اسفل منتصف الاحليل البولي مغلفة ذاتيًا جديدة مقابل الشريط المهبلي التقليدي في علاج سلس البول عند النساء ؛ دراسة مقارنة عشوائية مستقبلية", European Urology, 2023 More
  • Karim Mahmoud Taha Setta, "Buccal Mucosal Graft as a second layer in the vaginal Repair of Vesicovaginal Fistulas طعم الغشاء المخاطي الشدقي كطبقة ثانية في إصلاح المهبل في حالات الناسور المثاني المهبلي", Neurourology and Urodynamics, 2025 More
  • Karim Mahmoud Taha Setta, "Role of Renal Parynchyma to Hydronephrosis Area Ratio (PHAR) in predicting outcome after Pyeloplasty in children with Ureteroplevic Junction Obstruction (UPJO) دور نسبة حجم حمة الكلية إلى منطقة الموه الكلوي (PHAR) في توقع النتائج بعد جراحة ترميم الحويضة الكلوية لدى الأطفال المصابين بانسداد ملتقى الحالب والحوض الكلوي (UPJO)", Emirates Urological Society ICS –EUS-2025 ( Abu Dhabi ), 2025 More

Department Related Publications

  • Eslam Mohyeldeen, "Outcomes of Flank-Free Modified Supine Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy Based on BMI", Karger, 2020 More
  • Mohammed Salahuddin Rizk Dirie, "Comparative study between a new screwed Amplatz sheath and the ordinary one in percutaneous nephrolithotomy دراسة مقارنة بين غمدAmplatz مشدود جديدوالعادي في إستئصال حصاة الكلية عن طريق الجلـد", World Journal of Urology, 2021 More
  • Hazem Mohamed Algalaly, "SINGLE VERSUS MULTIPLE INSTILLATION OF POVIDONE IODINE AND UROGRAPHINE IN TREATMENT OF CHYLURIA A PROSPECTIVE RANDOMISED STUDY", Arab Journal of Urology, 2016 More
  • Alaa Abdallah Elsayed Haassaan, "SEMIRIGID URETEROSCOPY IN OBESE PATIENTS FOR TREATMENT OF LOWER URETERIC STONES AFTER FAILURE OF SWL: SAFETY AND EFFICAC", Egyptian Journal of Urology, 2015 More
  • Mohamed Mahmoud Salim Ismail, "RNA-binding proteins RBM-HuR, RBM3 and PODXL expression in urothelial carcinoma of the urinary bladder. Prognostic and clinical implications", pmc, 2021 More
Tweet