Evaluation of PPP software performance for TEC estimation using IRI-2020, CODE, COSMIC, and SWARM with GNSS data

Faculty Engineering Year: 2025
Type of Publication: ZU Hosted Pages:
Authors:
Journal: Journal of Applied Geodesy De Gruyter Volume:
Keywords : Evaluation , , software performance , TEC estimation using IRI-2020,    
Abstract:
This study evaluates the performance of two Precise Point Positioning (PPP) software solutions, GAPS and GAMP, for estimating Vertical Total Electron Content (VTEC). Their outputs were compared against the International Reference Ionosphere (IRI) models, the Center for Orbit Determination in Europe (CODE) solutions, SWARM satellite data, and COSMIC-1 observations. The results demonstrate that GAPS achieves superior accuracy and reliability after initialization, with VTEC estimates closely aligning with CODE, IRI, COSMIC-1, and SWARM data. In contrast, GAMP, while exhibiting faster convergence, showed greater variability and a tendency to underestimate VTEC, especially under dynamic ionospheric conditions. Statistical analyses revealed that GAPS produced lower Root Mean Square (RMS) errors across stations, with values below 20 Total Electron Content Units (TECU) when compared to CODE, IRI and between 5 and 25 TECU when validated against COSMIC-1 and SWARM data. Conversely, GAMP’s RMS values reached up to 65 TECU, indicating lower precision. GAPS also showed smaller average and absolute differences, confirming its ability to capture localized ionospheric variations more effectively than GAMP and IRI models. A t-test analysis indicated no statistically significant differences between GAPS and CODE, IRI, SWARM, or COSMIC-1 for most stations, demonstrating the robustness of GAPS in representing ionospheric behavior. GAMP, however, often exhibited significant differences in VTEC estimates relative to these references. These findings demonstrate GAPS’s superior performance in ionospheric studies and VTEC estimation, underscoring the importance of choosing suitable PPP solutions and prepossessing for high-precision GNSS and atmospheric research.
   
     
 
       

Author Related Publications

  • Mohamed Amin Abdelfatah, "Assessment of tropospheric delay models in GPS baseline data analysis: A case study of a regional network at Upper Egypt", civil engineering research magazine, 2009 More
  • Mohamed Amin Abdelfatah, "Precise troposphere delay model for Egypt, as derived from radiosonde data", Elsaiver, 2015 More
  • Mohamed Amin Abdelfatah, "Assessment of tropospheric delay mapping function models in Egypt Using PTD database model", Taylor & Francis, 2018 More
  • Mohamed Amin Abdelfatah, "Regional Egypt tropospheric mapping function model", ELSEVIER, 2018 More
  • Mohamed Amin Abdelfatah, "Performance Analysis of GNSS Networks: A Case Study of the Permanent Network in Egypt", International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 2019 More

Department Related Publications

  • Ahmed Elsayed Ali Mahmoud, "An Integrated Sustainable Construction Project’s Critical Success Factors (ISCSFs)", Sustainable Engineering and Science, 2021 More
  • Gamal Saber Ahmed Elfiky, "Determination of local gravimetric geoid model over Egypt using LSC and FFT estimation techniques based on different satellite- and ground-based datasets", Taylor & Francis, 2021 More
  • Mohammed Ahmed Ali Alashkar , "Determination of local gravimetric geoid model over Egypt using LSC and FFT estimation techniques based on different satellite- and ground-based datasets", Taylor & Francis, 2021 More
  • Ahmed Hussien Ibrahim Mahmmoud, "Management of Construction Cost Contingency Covering Upside and Downside Risks.", Alexandria Engineering Journal (AEJ),, 2014 More
Tweet