Ultrasound guided erector spinae plane block versus quadratus lumborum block for postoperative analgesia in patient undergoing open nephrectomy: A randomized controlled study مقارنة بين السدة العصبية لمستوي العضلة الناصبة الشوكية والسدة العصبية للعضلة المربعة القطنية باستخدام الموجات فوق الصوتية في المرضي الذين يخضعون لجراحة استئصال الكلية:دراسة عشوائية منضبطة

Faculty Medicine Year: 2021
Type of Publication: ZU Hosted Pages: 123–134
Authors:
Journal: EGYPTIAN JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA 2021, VOL. 37, NO. 1, 123–134 Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group. Volume:
Keywords : Ultrasound guided erector spinae plane block    
Abstract:
Background and Objective: Erector spinae plane block (ESPB) has been reported to provide analgesia in open abdominal surgeries in case reports or case series. We aimed to compare the effectiveness of ESPB and anterior Quadratus Lumborum block (QLB III) as a postoperative analgesic for open nephrectomy. Methods: Seventy five patients scheduled for open nephrectomy were randomly allocated into three equal groups (25 each); group (C) patients operated under general anesthesia while in (QLB and ESPB) groups, patients received general anesthesia followed by unilateral (QLBIII or ESPB) respectively, with 0.3–0.4 ml/kg of bupivacaine 0.25%. The primary outcome was the 24 h cumulative morphine given postoperatively. The secondary outcomes were the first rescue analgesic time, postoperative pain score, time to perform technique and sensory block coverage. Results: The 24 cumulative morphine consumption and first rescue analgesic time were significantly higher and shorter, respectively, in control group compared to the QLB and ESPB groups with no significant difference between interventional groups. VAS score at rest and during movement was significant higher in control group at all different timing measurements compared to the interventional groups. The block performing time was significant shorter in ESPB compared to QLB and the coverage of QLB extends from T8 to L2 and ESPB from T6 to T12. Conclusion: The ESPB is as efficient as QLB III to provide analgesia and decrease perioperative opioid consumption, taking into account the technically challenging and the time consuming of QLB III making ESPB a highly promising alternative for postoperative pain relief following open nephrectomyBackground and Objective: Erector spinae plane block (ESPB) has been reported to provide analgesia in open abdominal surgeries in case reports or case series. We aimed to compare the effectiveness of ESPB and anterior Quadratus Lumborum block (QLB III) as a postoperative analgesic for open nephrectomy. Methods: Seventy five patients scheduled for open nephrectomy were randomly allocated into three equal groups (25 each); group (C) patients operated under general anesthesia while in (QLB and ESPB) groups, patients received general anesthesia followed by unilateral (QLBIII or ESPB) respectively, with 0.3–0.4 ml/kg of bupivacaine 0.25%. The primary outcome was the 24 h cumulative morphine given postoperatively. The secondary outcomes were the first rescue analgesic time, postoperative pain score, time to perform technique and sensory block coverage. Results: The 24 cumulative morphine consumption and first rescue analgesic time were significantly higher and shorter, respectively, in control group compared to the QLB and ESPB groups with no significant difference between interventional groups. VAS score at rest and during movement was significant higher in control group at all different timing measurements compared to the interventional groups. The block performing time was significant shorter in ESPB compared to QLB and the coverage of QLB extends from T8 to L2 and ESPB from T6 to T12. Conclusion: The ESPB is as efficient as QLB III to provide analgesia and decrease perioperative opioid consumption, taking into account the technically challenging and the time consuming of QLB III making ESPB a highly promising alternative for postoperative pain relief following open nephrectomy
   
     
 
       

Author Related Publications

  • Shireen Elsayed AbdulLatif, "Pre-emptive nebulized ketamine versus nebulized lidocaine for endoscopic nasal surgeries رذاذ عقار الكيتامين الاستباقي في جراحات الأنف بالمنظار مقارنة برذاذ عقار الليدوكايين", Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow, 2020 More
  • Shireen Elsayed AbdulLatif, "Ultrasonographic evaluation of the effect of recruitment maneuvers and positive endexpiratory pressure on diaphragmatic functions in obese patients undergoing laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy: A randomized controlled study تقييم أثر مناورات التعبئة مع ضغط نهاية الزفير الإيجابي على وظائف الحجاب الحاجز في مرضى السمنة الخاضعين لجراحات "تكميم المعدة بالمنظار" باستخدام الموجات فوق الصوتية: دراسة عشوائية منضبطة", . Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group, 2020 More
  • Shireen Elsayed AbdulLatif, "Ultrasound-guided quadratus lumborum block versus transversus abdominis plane block in children undergoing laparoscopic appendectomy: a randomized clinical study مقارنة بين السدة العصبية للعضلة المربعة القطنية والسدة العصبية لمستوي العضلة الباطنية المستعرضة باستخدام الموجات فوق الصوتية في الأطفال الذين يخضعون لاستئصال الزائدة الدودية بالمنظار: دراسة عشوائية", Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow, 2020 More
  • Shireen Elsayed AbdulLatif, "Comparison of ultrasound-guided serratus plane block and thoracic paravertebral block for postoperative analgesia after thoracotomy: a randomized controlled trial مقارنة بين السدة العصبية المنشارية الأمامية والمجاورة للفقرات الصدرية باستخدام الموجات فوق الصوتية لتسكين الآم ما بعد جراحة بضع الصدر: تجربة عشوائية منضبطة", Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow, 2018 More
  • Shireen Elsayed AbdulLatif, "Transcranial Doppler role in prediction of post dural puncture headache in parturients undergoing elective cesarean section: prospective observational study دور الدوبلر الدماغي في التنبؤ بحدوث صداع ما بعد حقن الأم الجافية في مرضى الولادة القيصرية الاختيارية: دراسة ملاحظة مستقبلية", springer, 2019 More

Department Related Publications

  • Eslam Abdelrahman Soliman Elewa, "تخفيف الالم ودرجة الحصار الحركى ومسار المخاض فى النساء اللاتى تلدن للمرة الاولى وتتلقين اما تخدير فوق الام الجافية او تخديرا مشتركا تحت العنكبوتى وفوق الام الجافية او عقار المبريدين وريديا وذلك فى بداية المخاض الحقيقى", لايوجد, 1900 More
  • Eslam Abdelrahman Soliman Elewa, "سلامة الاستعمال المتكرر للحلول الوريدى الغروى الجديد ه س 130/04,(فوليوفن) مقارنة باستعمال محلول روريدى لاغروى فى المرضى ذوى الاصابات الدماغية", لايوجد, 1900 More
  • Ayman Abdelsalam Haasn, "تسكين ألام الولادة باستخدام عقلر الفتتانيل داخل الام الجافية يقلل الاستجابة الانفعالية للام", لايوجد, 1900 More
  • Ayman Abdelsalam Haasn, "مقارنة أخراج الانبوبة الحنجرية فى الاطفال مصحوبا بالشفط عنة بعد فتح الرئة بالاكسجين والاطفال تحت التخدير", لايوجد, 1900 More
  • Gamal Tohamy Ali Youssef, "التبطبيق الاكلينكى للتخدير النصفى باستخدام جرعة صغيرة من البيفياكين فى المرضى كبار السن المقرر لهم اجراء جراحة فى الجزء السفلى من البطن", لايوجد, 1900 More
Tweet