Systematic Comparison of the Influence of Different Data Preprocessing Methods on the Performance of Gait Classifications Using Machine Learning

Faculty Physical Education for Boys Year: 2020
Type of Publication: ZU Hosted Pages: 12
Authors:
Journal: Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology Frontiers Volume: 8
Keywords : Systematic Comparison , the Influence , Different Data Preprocessing Methods    
Abstract:
Human movements are characterized by highly non-linear and multi-dimensional interactions within the motor system. Therefore, the future of human movement analysis requires procedures that enhance the classification of movement patterns into relevant groups and support practitioners in their decisions. In this regard, the use of data-driven techniques seems to be particularly suitable to generate classification models. Recently, an increasing emphasis on machine-learning applications has led to a significant contribution, e.g., in increasing the classification performance. In order to ensure the generalizability of the machine-learning models, different data preprocessing steps are usually carried out to process the measured raw data before the classifications. In the past, various methods have been used for each of these preprocessing steps. However, there are hardly any standard procedures or rather systematic comparisons of these different methods and their impact on the classification performance. Therefore, the aim of this analysis is to compare different combinations of commonly applied data preprocessing steps and test their effects on the classification performance of gait patterns. A publicly available dataset on intra-individual changes of gait patterns was used for this analysis. Forty-two healthy participants performed 6 sessions of 15 gait trials for 1 day. For each trial, two force plates recorded the three-dimensional ground reaction forces (GRFs). The data was preprocessed with the following steps: GRF filtering, time derivative, time normalization, data reduction, weight normalization and data scaling. Subsequently, combinations of all methods from each preprocessing step were analyzed by comparing their prediction performance in a six-session classification using Support VectorMachines, RandomForest Classifiers,Multi-Layer Perceptrons, and Convolutional Neural Networks. The results indicate that filtering GRF data and a supervised data reduction (e.g., using Principal Components Analysis) lead to increased prediction performance of the machine-learning classifiers. Interestingly, the weight normalization and the number of data points (above a certain minimum) in the time normalization does not have a substantial effect. In conclusion, the present results provide first domainspecific recommendations for commonly applied data preprocessingmethods andmight help to build more comparable and more robust classification models based on machine learning that are suitable for a practical application.
   
     
 
       

Author Related Publications

  • Ibrahim Hamed Ibrahim Hassan, "The Effect of Core Stability Training on Dynamic Balance and Smash Stroke Performance in Badminton Players", Science Publishing Group, 2017 More
  • Ibrahim Hamed Ibrahim Hassan, "A comparative study between talented young Greek and German handball players in some physical and anthropometric characteristics", Biology of Sport, 2011 More
  • Ibrahim Hamed Ibrahim Hassan, "Covered Distance and Activity Profile of African Professional Soccer Players According to the Playing Position: Reports From Soccer World Cup 2014", TGFU, 2016 More
  • Ibrahim Hamed Ibrahim Hassan, "تأثير برنامج تدريبى لتطوير فعالية أداء الضربة الترجيحية من خط الـ 23م فى هوكى الميدان", كلية التربية الرياضية للبنين جامعة الاسكندرية, 2015 More
  • Ibrahim Hamed Ibrahim Hassan, "الخصائص الكينماتيكية للطرف العلوى وعلاقتها بسرعة الكرة أثناء أداء مهارة الإرسال العالى بوجه المضرب الأمامي فى الإسكواش", كلية التربية الرياضية للبنات بالجزيرة, 2016 More

Department Related Publications

  • Tarek Ezz Eldien Ibrahim Kelany, "تأثير التدريب الطولى على رفع مستوى الاداء المهارى لدى ناشىء هوكى الميدان", كلية التربية الرياضية للبنين, 2014 More
  • Ehab Saber Ismaiel Ismail, "The effectiveness of visual training on some attacking skills to youth squash", zagazig, 2009 More
  • Habib Reda Habib Ibrahiem, "تأثير استخدام الدوائر المغلقة والدوائر المفتوحة على تعلم بعض المهارات الأساسية في رياضة تنس الطاولة", كلية التربية الرياضية بالمنوفية, 2011 More
  • Habib Reda Habib Ibrahiem, "تأثير تدريبـات المقاومـة البالستية لتنمية القدرة العضلية على سرعة أداء اللعب الفردى لدى ناشئى كرة السرعة", كلية التربية الرياضية بالجزيرة, 2012 More
  • Habib Reda Habib Ibrahiem, "كينماتيكية الضربة اللولبية الخلفية وعلاقتها بسرعة الكرة في تنس الطاولة", كلية التربية الرياضية بنين بالزقازيق, 2013 More
Tweet